Monday, January 29, 2018

Whine & Dine with Watsham

Every now and then I like to write about what's happened over the past few months. It is a cathartic exercise for me, and hopefully offers something of interest to you. A common theme over the past few entries has been one of complaining about bad things that have happened. This may present an impression that I am a negative person who likes to whine about things. My friends can back me up that nothing could be further from the truth. I am naturally a very optimistic and positive person. I don't think I would have managed to start two video game companies of my own and developed titles such as Dementium, Mutant Mudds, Xeodrifter, and Chicken Wiggle without a hopeful outlook on the world.

If everything was going well, I would title this entry Fine Dining with Watsham. We're just not there... yet (there's that optimism).

My previous blog entry discussed the results of Chicken Wiggle's launch on 3DS, which was unfortunately less than stellar. However, once I picked myself from the floor and dusted myself off I was ready to make my mark on the Nintendo Switch with Mutant Mudds Collection.

Mutant Mudds' entry to the Switch library could have been a vanilla one. It would have been fine to release only Mutant Mudds Deluxe on Switch at $9.99 and then later release Mutant Mudds Super Challenge as a separate title. But I did not want to do that, because I believe first impressions can be important.

Instead, we set out to make Mudds on Switch special. Combining MMD and MMSC into a single game was a fun idea, and to top it off we decided to throw in a mudderized version of Bomb Monkey, called Mudd Blocks, which not only offers variety in gameplay to the trio, but also supports two player action. I was convinced this would be a big hit on the Switch among all the news of indie titles selling like hotcakes on the new platform.

Feeling good about the content of the game - having spent a lot of time and effort to add 100+ HD Rumble entries to cover every conceivable opportunity in the three games and support online leaderboards for all three games - I turned my attention to the other aspects that contribute to a games' successful launch: Pricing and PR.

My first thought was to set up Mutant Mudds Collection with a loyalty discount, so folks who purchased any of the muddy games on 3DS or Wii U would be able to buy the game at a lower cost. Unfortunately, this feature is not currently supported by Nintendo. OK, so the next best thing I could think of was to offer the game at a lower price as a pre-order so muddy fans could at least save some dough that way.

I wrestled with the pricing of the game for a long time. Many indie games had released at $19.99 on Switch, and that was becoming the norm at the time. But, due to the fact that MMC was a port of older games, and my thought that the indie gold-rush was coming to an end due to eShop saturation of games, I believed $14.99 would be a more attractive price. With that, I decided to put the game at $9.99 as a pre-order, which was surely a very appealing price for anyone interested in the games.

OK, great - that hurdle was figured out and now I needed to think about PR. I sent out dozens and dozens of codes to websites, youtubers, and anyone else who might give a little exposure of the game to a new audience - which is all fairly standard practice. In addition to this, I was fortunate enough to land a spot on IGN's Nintendo Voice Chat on the week the game was set to release. So cool!!

IGN is located in San Francisco, and I am located in Austin, Texas. I am becoming somewhat of a homebody as I get older, but this seemed like an opportunity I had to jump on. The folks at IGN are truly great people, and the chance to get the word out about MMC to an audience I may otherwise never reach was just too fabulous to miss. I invested in the time, flight, and hotel to make the appearance happen. It felt like an investment that would pay off.

I set up some Facebook ads as well as promoted some Tweets to try and get the word out during the pre-order period as well as post release. It's always difficult to gauge exactly how effective this can be, but I wanted to leave no stone unturned for Atooi's debut title on Nintendo Switch.

Nintendo's social channels on Twitter and Facebook are potentially massive opportunities to get the news out about your games to an audience who is likely interested in your game - or at least curious enough to check it out on the eShop. I emailed folks at NOA to put the game on their radar for consideration of inclusion in their social activity.

It felt like I did everything within my power to launch an interesting game on Nintendo Switch at a great price and get the word out so folks knew it was available. I had heard stories of games selling tens of thousands of copies within the first two weeks. Even though I always try to hope for the best and prepare for the worst, I truly felt that this could be a big hit for us.

I don't want to dive too deep into the sales details, because this blog entry is not purely about the sales of Mutant Mudds Collection, but more about everything that's going on right now. MMC has sold only "OK". I really shouldn't complain, but it's difficult to keep expectations in check when you read about success stories like Enter the Gungeon selling 75,000 copies in it's first two weeks. The same two weeks your game released, and you're seeing results less than 10% of that. The sales of MMC will help Atooi move along a little further, but I won't be throwing a celebratory party any time soon.

Why did Mutant Mudds Collection not sell as well as a game like Enter the Gungeon? It is difficult to say, exactly. Everyone will have their theories, and I expect many of them will be written in the comments section and/or tweeted at me. But, without actual data it's all anecdotal assumptions. The comparison of Mutant Mudds Collection and Enter the Gungeon is a very interesting one. Gungeon was originally released in April 2016 and Mutant Mudds Super Challenge was originally released in March 2016. Both are pixel games. Both were priced at $14.99. Gungeon was not offered at $9.99 as a pre-order, though. And, MMC is a collection of three games.

Enter the Gungeon was published by Devolver Digital, who is a fantastic publisher. I have many good friends who work at Devolver who I love and respect. I am truly happy for their success with this title, and for the developer who created it (Dodge Roll). But, I can't help but be a little jealous of their success over mine and try to determine what might have contributed to the different results. I always assume I made mistakes, and I expect I made many, but I also look for significantly different events that may have contributed to one games' success over another similar title.

I know that Devolver Digital is very good at promoting their games, and I am certain that this played a big part in the games' success. Maybe I just need to work with them... hmmm!? Another key event that I noticed happening prior to the launch of our games and on release day was the activity on Nintendo of America's twitter channel. Enter the Gungeon was retweeted prior to the games' release - announcing the release dates - and was also retweeted on launch day. I know that this may not be the singular reason a game will sell 75,000 copies in its first two weeks, but being tweeted out to over 8 million folks sure won't hurt.

I should add that I was thrilled and deeply appreciative when I saw Mutant Mudds Collection included on the Switch news channel as one of the indie titles highlighted for December. I have no data on how many folks view the news channels on the Switch, but it was wonderful to be included.

As a quick side note, if Mutant Mudds Collection sold 75,000 copies we would be looking at NET revenue of over $780,000. WOW! That would literally change Atooi's future over night. It is difficult for me to think of this in light of it being possible but not achieved with Mutant Mudds Collection, but I have to look at it as something that is still achievable and soldier on with that goal. I have had to do this multiple times in my career as an indie developer, and this is no different. One day I will achieve this sort of success, and I will use that success to make games that knock your socks off!

So, what's next? If you follow me on twitter you may already know that Xeodrifter is coming to Nintendo Switch February 15 for $9.99. After the exhaustive efforts I put into setting up MMC for success and its sales not meet that effort, I am opting for a more restrained and simple release of Xeodrifter. No pre-order. No triple pack. Just bringing an excellent mini Metroid game to Switch at a reasonable price. We did take the time to add HD Rumble and make sure the game runs super smooth and awesome on the Switch. Fingers crossed it finds its audience.

I have also announced that Totes the Goat is coming to Switch. This is a port of Atooi's very first game. A mobile title I released as a side project while still active with Renegade Kid. The original game was developed in Unity, so bringing it to Switch was fairly quick and simple. We still took the time to polish it up nice and pretty for the Switch, and added some new playable characters for players to unlock. Totes is going through Nintendo lotcheck now. No firm release date yet. It will be priced $4.99 and not have any of the ads or in-game purchases of the mobile release.

We have a new previously unannounced game that will be coming out in time for the World Cup! WHAT!? I know, right!! It is a fun side project that we've been kicking around for a while now (pun intended). It's an arcade soccer game, called Soccer Slammers. Taking inspiration from NBA Jam, Soccer Slammers is a 2-on-2 arcade soccer experience focused on fast, fun gameplay for Nintendo Switch.

We'll be bringing Soccer Slammers to GDC to show it off to anyone who's interested. :)

What else? So much more!! I'll get to Treasurenauts in a sec. But, first... Chicken Wiggle: Re-hatched. I put the call out to folks in the twitterverse to gauge interest in potentially running a Kickstarter campaign to bring an HD version of Chicken Wiggle to Nintendo Switch. Even though I know results on twitter are no guarantee, the most I expected to get from asking is whether this was a good idea or a terrible idea. I conclude it is a good idea! More on a Kickstarter campaign for Chicken Wiggle: Re-hatched coming soon!

And now, onto Treasurenauts!!! Treasurenauts is going to be fantastic. If there is one thing that I have learned from the recent releases is that nothing is as exciting as a new game. It can be a port of your favorite game, but it's still something you've already experienced. A new game!? That is full of potential and excitement.

Treasurenauts is something that I have worked on and off for many years now. I first revealed the game back in 2013, which was clearly too early. :) It has been a really fun project to revisit. Each game that I have worked on and even each game that I have played has contributed to what Treasurenauts is today. It is the amalgamation of everything that I have learned about platformers, and it is a game that is truly special to me.

The design of Treasurenauts is complete. I continue to tweak small details of the design here and there, but the bulk of what Treasurenauts is has been established. Now, we just need to finish all of the content and wrap it up. I have no doubt in my mind that it will be my most ambitious and best platformer that I've had the pleasure of working on. I am constantly surprised and thrilled that people are still out there asking about the game and demanding its release.

The reason the game has taken so long is because it is larger in scope than my other platformers, and as such can't be rushed. However, that also means that it is not earning money for Atooi. Therefore, other games must be developed and released in order to generate money to enable us to continue with development. This is why games like Xeodrifter, Mutant Mudds Super Challenge, Chicken Wiggle, and Soccer Slammers exist. They were each a delight to develop, and they all fit within a time period shorter than Treasurenauts, which made them great candidates to release and generate cash. Admittedly, Chicken Wiggle development totally went off the rails and ended up taking 16 months, but I am proud of the results. :)

I will be bringing a playable of Treasurenauts to E3 2018. I will have more news on the game at that time. Until then, thank you for your continued support.

Now, before I go: I wrote this for me and for the folks out there who care about me and want to know what's going on in my life. If you see this as whining or want to give me shit for it. Go fuck yourself. :) I don't usually swear publicly - even though I swear like a sailor privately - but, it's getting to the point where people sending me asshole comments on my blog and twitter is just getting boring and tiring. I don't care about your negative comments. They are a reflection of you. Not me.

To the lovers out there - keep on loving. I love you all! 💓


  1. Jools Watsham sir...I need a hard copy collection of everything on a single game card, Make my Dream come true!! A big fan named Roto <3

  2. Huge fan of your work here, I'm hoping MMC will at least have a bit of a long tail and keep selling for a while even if not in huge amounts at a time. I'll be keeping an eye out for the Chicken Wiggle kickstarter!

  3. I'm curious about Soccer Slammers. I hope you can show some footage relatively soon.

  4. Well-written and well-missed, sir! Been a fan since the first Dementium. :) The future is bright and your new game looks fun. Endure and prosper.

  5. Jools you do great work man i've grabbed every game you made thus far at least twice (Wii U/3DS/PS4/Switch). You were one of the indie devs that shaped how i handle my indie game development from both business side ,and game design side.

    Now if i could only get Booty Diver as recognizable to fans as you have with something like Mudds. Hell i remember when Mudds was a 3D Nintendo DS platformer.

    Keep your head up man....there are some of us that are always rooting for you.

  6. It really is sad to hear that Mutant Mudds Collection didn't sell as well as it should have. For all the frustration I got with Super Challenge's... well, super challenge, the game is well worth the price, especially if you don't suck as much as I do.

  7. Great blog. Thank you for the updates on the projects. A lot of gamers complain because said game hasn't released yet and it has been years. Yet, they have years worth of backlog games they need to play through. Maybe if they played their backlog the could unlock the hidden "Treasure-naughts". Pun intended.

  8. I love Mutant Mudds. However I didn't buy it on Switch. I really enjoyed the game already on Wii U and on 3DS. Plus I got it as a freebie on PS+ for Vita.

    I thought the game was already difficult enough so I have not especially wanted to play Super Challenge. Also, I can usually not get into puzzle games in the style of Mudd Blocks.

    Those are the reasons why I personally didn't buy the Mutant Mudds collection on Switch. One game that I already have on plenty of other platforms that I don't feel I need to play again, one game that looks great but would probably be too challenging for me, and one game that I probably would not play very much.

    $10 or $15 is a great price and for anyone who has not played Mutant Mudds, I would completely recommend buying the collection. But I just didn't have a reason to do so myself.

  9. I echo CompC's comments on Mutant Mudds... Awesome game, but the Switch version would have been redundant for me (I bought it when it first came out on 3DS), and there are so many great indie games on Switch right now.

    I played Xeodrifter on 3DS and loved it, and for me it cemented that you're a great designer with sensibilities that match my own... when you do work in the genres I gravitate to. I've eagerly awaited Treasurenauts, but sadly I skipped out on Chicken Wiggle because... I had moved on from 3DS. So I hope that game comes to Switch.

    In any case, I've been following your career for years now, and I admire your work and spirit greatly. Don't let the naysayers get to you. I believe your audience will continue to find you over time as your newer projects coalesce.

  10. As someone who absolutely adored Mutant Mudds, it's really sad to hear that Mutant Mudds Collection hasn't sold that well. Admittedly, I'm part of the problem, though, since I haven't bought it yet—I would have, had you not announced plans for a physical release this year. I'm not sure if that's still in the cards or not, but I hope it is. I have nothing against digital releases, but I'll always go with a physical release over digital if that's an option, mainly because my husband and I share our games, and we can't share digital games.

    I'm very excited for Treasurenauts, though, as that's been one of my most anticipated indie games for years now! Hopefully things will pick up for Atooi in 2018, because you make quality, polished games and deserve good sales for it! And hopefully Nintendo will better spotlight your games in the future. I'm convinced that a big part of why MMC didn't do that well is because Nintendo didn't really feature it much at all like they've done with other indie games. Not sure why that is, but if I had to guess it's probably because they want to focus on new games rather than ports/collections like that. Hopefully Treasurenauts can get that extra push from Nintendo!

  11. Suggestion: I don't know how much depth you're looking to give Soccer Slammers, but the Switch allows 8 local players. Perhaps you could add a 4-on-4 mode, if possible.

    Just a thought.

  12. How ironic that being one of the most enduring Nintendo supporters as far as Indie developers actually hurting the company right now (with all the "I already have it on 3DS/WiiU" "Was too hard for me the first time").

    And instead, companies that wouldn´t give Nintendo fans the time of the day back in the day, are now getting rich with the Switch userbase.

  13. This comment has been removed by the author.

  14. I think your games would benefit from having a more unique personality, presentation wise. This doesn't mean they are generic, i just mean that striving to make them more unique would help you stand out. You use the example of Enter the Gungeon. While both Mutant Mudds and Enter the Gungeon have rock solid gameplay - that game oozes personality. Yes, yours is a small team with limited resources but you have the retro part of Atooi's slogan down to a science, a little more of that modern mojo would go a long way. I think your pixel art is superior to the art in Slime San, for example, but that game's colour palette made it pop. So did Gonner's art style. Conversely, if the art style is going for a classic look - that game should have a hook other than rock solid gameplay to make it stand out. Either a gimmick, a novel mechanic or a cool narrative. I would't dare to tell you how your games should look or play, it's just that as vibrant as Mutant Mudds looks on my Switch, as lovely as the pixel art is, if I was an average joe gamer, I wouldn't have noticed it amongst the sea of games out there.

    The reason that my favourite game of yours is Xeodrifter is cause It had a bit of grit and weirdness. Imagine, just as an example, if Mutant Mudds had played up the sci-fi aspect of the Mudds, went for a grainy black and white 50's aesthetic and a Danny-Elfman-Goes-Chiptune-style soundtrack. That wouldn't make it a better game, but if I saw that version of Mutant Mudds and i'd never heard of it i'd be intrigued, not cause I love old timey sci-fi, but because it would look different, "unique", it would stand out. I'm sorry if I'm over the line, un-requested advice is annoying but I hope when I see a new game of yours it will pop among the vast sea of pixels that is the indie scene.

    I'll surely buy any new game you put out no matter what, but I hope that others see it too and then we get to read a "Switch-success tweet" from you. You deserve your hard work to become a success story.
    I'm always rooting for you and your games, You come off a decent dude and you make good games.

  15. My advice is ....don't give up. We all know that you don't make bad games.
    I am sure the success will come. I am sure it will be on switch. You just need the right game and the right timing....and certainly more exposure
    I have high hopes for chicken wiggle on Switch. It will be day 1 purchase for me :)

  16. I'm looking forward to it all!
    I'm especially excited about soccer slammers.

  17. I'm really excited for everything, honestly, but most so with soccer slammers. I love couch co-op games.

  18. Thank you for the fantastic read Jools! I can’t image how hard the gaming industry can be, but I’m super happy that your a part of it. Keep up the fantastic work!

  19. Great blog that, Jools. No it isn’t negative or whiny in the slightest. I appreciate you sharing your experiences with fans of your games!

    I for one, expect Chicken Wiggle and Treasurenauts on Switch to be your biggest success stories to date. Not many Switch owners will know much of Chicken Wiggle – effectively making it a new game – and Treasurenauts has been on many gamers 'must own' lists for the best part of five years!

    In the meantime, I really and sincerely hope that Xeodrifter, Totes the Goat and Soccer Slammers do really good numbers for you. You utterly deserve the most success.

    Best wishes,
    Simon Potticary
    Twitter: @simonpotticary

  20. My personal take: I enjoyed MM back on 3DS but there was no real incentive for me to double dip. There was with Gungeon however since I wasn't able to play it on a portable before. Personally I haven't seen any ads or anything on Gungeon, I knew from forums etc. it was coming, same with MMC.

  21. You're awesome jools - as an aspiring indie developer myself currently working on my first game, it's always super interesting to hear your thoughts. Don't let the ass hole comments get you down - I guarantee that they're either just kids who don't know better, or they're just angry IRL and using you as target

    Hyped for all your Switch projects- I'll support them all :-D

  22. Hey Jools!

    I have purchased Mutant Mudds, Super Challenge, Bomb Monkey, Xeodrifter, Chicken Wiggle and Moon Chronicles Ep. 1 on 3DS. I am a fan of your work, especially Mutant Mudds and Super Challenge. I haven't bought Mutant Mudds on Switch just because I don't normally re-buy games I already own and have beaten. Really looking forward to Treasurenauts though! Keep up the good work.

  23. That was a good read. I preordered MMC despite owning the games on 3DS/Wii U, just so you know :)

    I'm no expert, but I would recommend releasing Dementium (maybe a Collection of both games) on Switch. There aren't many quality horror games, or FPS style games, available for Switch, and I believe a combination of the two would succeed (with all due respect) more than 'pixel' games, which are in abundance on the eShop.


  24. nice post!!

    This blog was very useful for me waiting for more blog.

    SAP MM Training in Chennai

  25. The Interior Designer is a plans, researches, coordinates, and manages the projects. Interior design is a multifaceted profession that includes conceptual development, space planning, site inspections, programming, research, communicating with the stakeholders of a project, construction management, and execution of the design.

    Interior Designers in OMR


  26. This is extremely helpful info!! Very good work. It is very interesting to learn and easy to understood.
    Android Training Institute in chennai

  27. This blog is really helpful regarding all educational knowledge I earned. It covered a great area of subject which can assist a lot of needy people. Everything mentioned here is clear and very useful. สล็อต scr

  28. Healthisgod is the only complete health and wellness website that you may describe as it yours. We created a site that introduces the collection of health and lifestyle information supported by reliable content providers and genuine user reviews. This is a sincere effort on our part to bring forth a user experience which is engaging, moving, and interactive. Visit for more- Health is God

  29. I’ve been writing essays for how many years and today I’m more on academic essay writing and I’m happy to be like my dad, a professional writer.Read more Kim kardashian sex tape and Mia Khalifa Sex video and Sunny Leone Sexy Movie

  30. Nutra Trials defines personal characteristics of different health products including skincare, weight loss, muscle and male enhancement. The study presented here is briefly described for reader convenience and to deliver them assurance with health standards. The best possible answers are given here regarding the selection of an ideal supplement or cream or serum that possibly remains to be safe for health and do not cause any side effects.

  31. It is a great job, I like your posts and wish you all the best. and I hope you continue this job well.
    NutraT line